We walk up our inclined street on a warm afternoon. We take brisk strides. We say nothing for a while and enjoy the sunshine. It feels like any other day but I know it’s not. We head east on Erie and I noticed the city’s finally gotten around to mowing the public grass.
Neither of us say anything. I rack my brain for analogy, some example where everything turned up aces for everybody. I can’t come up with an athlete whose old team and new team both benefitted from his departure, though I’m sure the examples exist.
We walk up a hidden staircase, a secret neighborhood treasure, because everyone should have a chance to take these steps and one of us is running out of chances. I stumble through a couple attempts at starting the dreadful conversation. It’s a little embarrassing, but ultimately okay because I get the sense no one is listening.
We reach the top of the cement stairs and the observatory is a couple hundred yards away. A little boy pedals his bike in a big circle in the gravel parking lot. He’s all smiles. His mother stands in the middle of the circle. She’s all grimaces.
The boy wears a helmet that looks too big for him. He hits the brakes and says hello to us and smiles. I tell him hi. He seems like a sweet kid. His good day juxtaposes with what I have to do and I smirk. I decide it’s time to be out with it—just shoot first and ask questions later.
“Look,” I say, avoiding eye contact like a foreman holding a guilty verdict, “this just isn’t working. I know you’re not happy, and frankly, neither am I. You and my girl definitely don’t click, and I think it’s best for everybody if we go our separate ways. It doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with you or that there’s any wrong with us. It’s just not a good fit. What do you think?”
I crouch down and stroke his head. He lifts his leg and pees on a bush.
For the last week or so, a rescue dog named Duke has been staying with us. Duke is a five or six year-old Miniature Pinscher with an overbite that gives him a permanent smile. He’s a twelve-pound love bug who’s happy as long as he has a person to snug with and a blanket in which to burrow. Like I told him, he’s someone’s perfect dog, just not ours.
We’d been discussing bringing another dog into the house for several weeks. We spent hours surfing dog adoption sites looking for the right characteristics to complement the personality of our two year-old Min Pin/Pug mix Fiona. She needed a buddy, we thought. Someone to pal around with. We were sure Duke was the guy.
We liked that he’s a little older than her. We thought his wisdom and subdued nature would influence her to relax a bit. We hoped that he had some good habits she could imitate.
For a few days, it looked like we were right. Duke is crate-trained and house-trained. He comes when he’s called. He’s sweet-natured to us, and he’s a cute boy. Come on. Just look at that face.
He and Fiona spent a couple days figuring out who was boss. Tension was high, but once the hierarchy was set and the queen assumed the throne, the electricity in the air tamped down some. The canine partnership wasn’t violent but it wasn’t perfect either. If I pet one dog, the other would come over to break up the fun. Fiona couldn’t get Duke to play with her much, no matter how hard she tried, and the frustration was written all over her wrinkled forehead. If Duke were on the couch with us, Fiona would lie on the floor and face the other direction. She didn’t like having an interloper in her home, and she disliked us for bringing him there.
On a Saturday morning, I got the bright idea to take them on individual walks. I figured I could bond with one while Liz bonded with the other, then we’d trade. The plan was flawless. Until, that is, a leash was involved.
All our research told us to support the power dynamic the dogs created. Since Fiona is the alpha, she does everything first. We feed her first, we let her outside first, we pet her first. She’s the doggie boss and we treat her that way. These walks were no different; Fiona got to go first. As soon as I attached the leash to her harness Duke went ballistic. He barked at her and ran around our living room like a maniac. Frightened, Fiona started trotting around as if to say “Nothing to see here. Nope. Just a couple-a dogs having a normal day.” Duke started keeping pace with her, only snarling and nipping at her neck.
We chalked it up to nerves, but it was the first sign of Duke’s fracture from the rest of the pack.
When we traded dogs, Duke again barked and howled like a pup possessed. Once the hand off was made, he settled and we went on a pleasant early morning walk. We passed a park where a youth soccer team was practicing. We walked by kids swinging from jungle gyms and nervous parents standing vigil nearby. Runners went by us. We didn’t meet any dogs though, which was peculiar. We live in a dog-centric community. We’re talking about a neighborhood that allows pups in restaurants, where people set bowls of water on sidewalk corners. Yet that morning, we didn’t cross a single dog.
The evening of the walk, the four of us went to an event called the Furry Friends Festival. Dogs and their owners filled Cincinnati’s Washington Park for live music, craft beer, and summertime fun. It was a celebration of the kinship between man and dog, and exactly the kind of silly event we find irresistible.
We were especially excited because we’d picked up a “Y”-shaped leash extension from PetSmart, so the two dogs, brother and sister in our eyes, could trot around being cute together. We spent months envisioning this scene, and the dream was moments from coming true.
We unloaded them from the back of my SUV and hooked them together so they could walk side-by-side. A large dog passed us in the parking lot. This is where the night went haywire. Duke bucked and jumped and barked and spit and lunged and howled. There was too much distance between them for Duke to reach the other animal, but that didn’t stop him from trying. Like us, Fiona didn’t know what to do, so everyone kept walking toward the park hoping Duke’s fit would pass. It didn’t.
He repeated the same lunatic routine to every dog we encountered and began baring his fangs at Fiona. That led us to believe the “Y” leash was the culprit, so we split the dogs up; Liz took Fiona, and I took Duke. The closer we got to the park, the more intense he became. It was frightening. I felt like an embarrassed father trying to talk his son out of a tantrum in the middle of a Target, only my son comes from wolves and he might hurt me or someone else. What was especially odd is Duke directed none of his venom at people. When dog-less walkers passed, he’d quiet down and act friendly again. But as soon as one of his furry brothers entered the frame, a switch flipped.
A friend of ours was meeting us there. She hadn’t planned on going, but we convinced her to go. She strolled up with her two dogs just after I told Liz we needed to leave. Liz did the polite thing and explained our predicament to her friend while I tried to hang on to a twelve-pound hurricane. The conversation went on too long for me and I lost my cool and yelled at Liz that we had to go. Not my best moment.
We were quiet and humiliated on the ride home. We had no clue Duke could go primal like that, and it troubled us. We got the dogs inside and crated them. Then we did what any sensible people would do: We went out for margaritas.
We spent most of the night talking about he incident at the park and what it means and whether we could keep Duke knowing that we don’t know what he’s capable of doing to us, to Fiona, to our friend’s newborn, to anyone. I blamed us. I said we should have known better than to take him to an event like that so early. We wouldn’t have done that with Fiona, I reasoned.
The next day in church, we watched a video of a couple that adopts kids with illnesses and special needs. Seven children live in their home, and each one of them has a serious medical problem. The first kid they adopted wasn’t supposed to live longer than two weeks, but they brought him home anyway. The whole crowd went misty-eyed, me included. This video played over and over in my head as I contemplated what to do about Duke. With that family in mind, I stuck my neck out.
I made an impassioned plea to Liz that I didn’t want to be the kind of person who gives up, I didn’t want to be a coward. Duke is the way he is because people gave up on him, I told her. We’re better than that. And Liz hugged me and graciously agreed to keep the little guy.
We canceled his appointment for the temperament test we’d scheduled at the doggie day care where Fiona goes a couple times a week, but we vowed to bring him back when he was ready. We talked about paying for extensive training, the kind of 2-3 week program where the dog boards somewhere else and returns to you reprogrammed. We even took him to meet a trainer, an older guy who talks like Billy Bob Thornton’s character in Sling Blade. This trainer, Dave we’ll call him, has no use for punctuation. His sentences go on for days.
“You bring the dog here once a week for ten weeks I’ll train him down stay sit heel When the dog barks you give him a good correction with a choker that’s all he needs Some people are real namby-pamby about the correction and it never sticks You come in for the last few sessions tell me what’s going on and I’ll show ya how to fix it And I don’t believe in evolution but monkey see monkey do”
I’m sure I didn’t catch it all. We’d brought both dogs along, thinking Fiona could use some brushing up on her basic obedience training, and Dave took each dog for a test drive.
“This’n here,” he said, pointing to Fiona, “is a piece a cake The other’n is a bit challenged.”
Sadly, that made us feel relieved. The drive home from Dave the dog trainer’s was spent trying to invent reasons to keep Duke. But we knew we couldn’t. Even if we’d spent a good chunk of money training him, there were no guarantees: We still wouldn’t know what he might do. Plus, we adopted him thinking we’d bring more love and more happiness into our home, and that wasn’t the case. Everyone was anxious all the time, including Duke. Until he could be accepted at daycare, he had to be crated all but a few hours a day. That’s no kind of life for a dog.
By the time we pulled up the driveway, we had decided to give Duke back to the adoption agency. Guilt worked its black alchemy on us in the days that followed. I’d think about it and get choked up. Liz beat herself up pretty bad. Part of it is feeling like a failure. Part of it is knowing some awful things probably happened to Duke to make him this way. But I know in my heart that we aren’t the right people for him.
The program said they couldn’t take him back until today, so we did our best to give Duke a big send off weekend. He’s been on several walks and we’ve allowed him to sleep in our bed. (I draw the line at under the covers, but he tries.) Friday morning he came to the office with me, and yesterday he and Fiona took a dip in a doggie pool. We’re determined to send him out with a bang.
We’ve added Duke to our prayers. We hope he finds an older couple that can spend all day with him, snuggling up on a recliner and watching TV. He needs a pair of hands that have nothing better to do than rub his belly. He needs a homebody that is always ready to toss a blanket on him for a good game of “Ghost.” We just aren’t those people. I hope Duke forgives us for that. I hope we forgive us for that too.